Why All Mineral and Waste Valuations Are Not Equal

In the specialist property sectors in which we work (minerals, waste, energy, heavy industrial), we are often presented with the general client request that ‘we need a valuation’.  Any competent valuer and Chartered Mineral Surveyor will always follow up that initial request with a check as to ‘what do you need the valuation for and how are you wanting to use it?’ And that is because not all valuations are the same in form or function.

Mineral valuation

Minerals and waste valuations are always dictated by their end purpose, as the purpose will drive the valuation basis, the valuation methodology and whether the valuation is governed by formal reporting standards. The first two factors will dictate how a valuer approaches and calculates the value of a property and will always affect the reported figure. It is for this reason that valuers who approach every property and valuation purpose the same way, will often end up mis-reporting value and causing headaches (or worse) for their instructing clients. It is essential that the purpose of the valuation is clear to, and agreed by, all parties from the outset.


All valuations undertaken by Chartered Surveyors need to be undertaken having first checked whether they fall within the RICS Valuation Standards, commonly referred to as ‘The Red Book’. These mandatory standards set out the key steps, bases and considerations that valuers must take account of and capture a wide range of regulated valuations. These include valuations for secured lending and valuations for financial statements amongst others. They set out stringent requirements on how a valuer approaches every stage of their report from the taking of instructions, through site inspections, record keeping, methodology, considering value and reporting their findings. Many of these requirements should be followed whether or not the valuation is a regulated valuation.


Some valuations, identified as “exceptions” fall outside the strict application of the RICS standards (including, for example, valuations for internal discussion purposes to inform business strategy) and can be more flexible in their approach and method. Whilst some of the Red Book standards will apply, a valuer providing advice in such exceptional cases can depart to some degree from methodologies, perhaps providing a range of values, or values that fit ‘what if?’ scenarios. It is essential however that the valuer makes clear that the valuation is an exception to the full Red Book regulation and explains why in their report. It should also be clear that the valuation should not be used for any other than the stated purpose. A key reason for this is that changing the approach and methodology can, and does, change reported value. A client that has not been informed of this at the outset and uses a valuation falling within the exceptional criteria for a formal, regulated, purpose will be asking for trouble. Likewise, a competent valuer will not allow a valuation to be used for the wrong purpose and should never simply be ‘signing off’ an exceptional approach as a formal valuation.


Over the years the RICS have taken great care to improve and strengthen their standards for property valuation but sadly we still see a  number of negligence claims on which we are asked to provide Expert Valuation advice where Valuers have adopted the ‘one size fits all’ approach, resulting in their clients incurring losses. Sadly, despite the standards it is clear that some valuers are not following them!

At Matthews & Son LLP, as an RICS Regulated Firm we take our valuation responsibilities most seriously. All our valuation reports are prepared by RICS Registered Valuers with many years’ experience with these specialist properties and are always peer reviewed by another valuer before issue. The Standards may seem overwhelming and, to some, a ‘nuisance’, but explaining to clients WHY we follow them is a key part of the valuation process. Valuations are not all created equal!

CONTACT

Andrew Crawford

T 07969 889779

E ac@matthewsandson.co.uk

Paul Malam

T 07535 673618

E pjm@matthewsandson.co.uk

Appointment to RICS President’s Panel of Arbitrators

A new senior level professional appointment for Andrew Crawford, a Chartered Surveyor and Partner in the Matthews & Son LLP team.

(more…)

Business Rates Reform

As you may be aware, HMG announced in the 2020 budget that it would conduct a fundamental review of business rates in England.  Matthews & Son are advising on the consultation through various channels.

(more…)

Planning For The Future

Opencast quarry site minerals

Matthews & Son are currently considering the Governments consultation on reforms to the planning system.

(more…)

The Importance of Using a Chartered Mineral Surveyor

In the field of property advice, it is generally understood what a Chartered Surveyor is. But is a Chartered Mineral Surveyor the same thing? Here we provide some explanation!

(more…)

The Importance of Long Term Relations in Minerals and Waste Leases

Matthews & Son LLP have many years experience in long term minerals and waste leases and are well versed with avoiding the pitfalls. But what are they?

(more…)

The Importance of Long Term Relations in Minerals and Waste Leases

Matthews & Son LLP have many years experience in long term minerals and waste leases and are well versed with avoiding the pitfalls. But what are they?

(more…)

The Importance of Knowing What Lies Beneath!

For many of us, the materials that lie beneath our land are things that we most likely take for granted. They simply represent the ‘earth’ or the ‘ground’ and need no further thought in most cases. But there are also times when it can be extremely helpful to know exactly what lies beneath the surface of your property. Matthews & Son LLP has many years experience of assisting landowners and developers in this area, for a variety of reasons.

UK Geological map
 

(more…)

Matthews & Son LLP Minerals and Waste Team Strengthen Expert Witness Service

 

Matthews & Son LLP are pleased to announce that Simon Chaffe and Paul Malam have been added to the RICS Register of Expert Witnesses.

(more…)